12-17-2007 CHCMCharter Commission
Minutes
December 17, 2007
Members Present: Chair Mike Cannon, Deb Roepke, Linda Remucal, Ron McGraw,
Mark Cormier, Judy Simons and Walt Clay
Members Absent: Virgil Voight and Roger Stearns
Mike Cannon called the meeting to order at 4:09 p.m.
Mr. Cannon noted that the meeting was called today to meet statutory requirements that
the Charter Commission meet one time annually. Mr. Cannon asked if anyone had any
items that needed to be discussed. Mr. Cannon noted that Marc Sebora, City Attorney,
informed him that the Mayor would like to have the Charter Commission look at giving
the Mayor the power to make a motion. Mr. Cannon further noted that the charter does
not prevent the Mayor from making motions and that is something he feels is the City
Council's decision to make. Mr. Cannon also noted that he feels the hospital privatization
should be taken out of the charter completely since it is a separate entity.
Marc Sebora, City Attorney noted that the City Council does not know what to do with
the HAHC Board. The hospital will be a separate entity but the City acts as a landlord
still owning the buildings and land for the next 30 years. Mr. Sebora further noted that
there is criteria set forth if the hospital were to default; the assets would revert back to the
City. The City Council is not sure if they should dissolve the board or keep it running.
Mr. Sebora noted that this is something for the Charter Commission to consider for next
year. Mr. Sebora further noted he would recommend that the hospital section be deleted
or amended in the charter.
Mr. Clay inquired of whether there were scenarios where the City got the hospital back.
Mr. Clay recommended that they amend the charter instead of deleting it completely, so
if the hospital were to default something would still be in the charter.
Mr. Sebora commented that the City is concerned about getting the deal complete.
Mrs. Remucal noted that the Charter Commission does not have to decide today what to
do about the charter, they have until the elections.
Mr. Clay noted that they should get the City's recommendations and then the
Commission will make the changes.
Mrs. Remucal inquired about the whether the HHC Board includes all new members.
Mr. Sebora noted that the HHC Board will consist of seven members and of those seven
members the City will pick three members and of those three one will be a City Council
representative. Discussion was held.
Mr. Cannon noted that the City should move forward with the deal and the Charter
Commission will act when needed. Mr. Cannon also noted about the City communication
issue that is happening with City staff and the City Council. Mr. Cannon noted that in the
charter it specifically states that the City Council can not give orders to staff Mr. Cannon
inquired whether or not the charter needed to be changed.
Mr. Sebora noted that Robert Honke is the person who says it should be addresses and
the provisions stricken, and that City Council members should be able to talk with
employees.
Mr. Clay noted that he feels the sections about Boards and Commissions not being able to
communicate by email went over the edge and it would be hard for members to
communicate.
Mr. Sebora noted that Council Member Casey Stotts will be taking out the Boards and
Commissions section. Discussion was held.
Mr. Cannon also noted that the Charter Commission is short three members. Mr. Cannon
further noted that if anyone knew of anyone who would serve on the Charter Commission
they should let him know. Mr. Cannon inquired whether they needed the full 12 members
and what makes the quorum, half of 12 or half of the nine members. Mr. Cannon further
noted that the City has tried to find people to serve, and have been unsuccessful.
Mr. Sebora noted that the state requirement is that the Charter Commission has between 8
and 13 members and the City Ordinance requires the Charter Commission have 12
members. Mr. Sebora further noted that if they would like to drop to nine members it
would have to be approved by City Council. Mr. Sebora further noted that he would
recommend the Charter Commission meet sometime in early 2008 to discuss the hospital
revisions.
With no further business to discuss, a motion was made by Clay, seconded by McGraw to
adjourn at 4:27 p.m.